Congrats to the ones who made the cut.
1. The stench of blood can ruin a spring morning.
2. Friggen appropriate, the bathroom door opens and my life goes down the toilet.
6. If she’d been a bad girl when she had the chance, she probably wouldn’t be dying right now.
7. Frustrated, Ezra shot the mysterious message one last piercing stare before tossing the note on his desk beside its mate.
8. Camels.
11. Death lurked in the shadows, and I knew it searched for me.
12. Sometimes ghosts can be so rude.
13. When I was six and she was nine, my cousin Claudia told me to touch the electric fence.
14. My mother always wanted me to become a beautician, and as I unzipped the body bag of the three-hundred pound corpse, I snapped the lip of my neoprene glove for not heeding her advice.
15. It started out so innocently -- with a chamois cloth, some silver polish, and a bottle of Brasso.
19. If you’re running from the law and you are the law, don’t forget your sunscreen.
20. You can’t rewrite history with a bulldozer, Mr. Maxwell.”
21. I never thought I would be considered a home wrecker, but it's what I became
22. Rowen's first anniversary was definitely not the best time for her husband to show up missing.
23, What I wanted would kill me.
28. The two old Voodoo priestesses faced each other in the single-room shack, their eyes wide with fear.
29. Getting shot was a bitch - every time.
32. The stitch in Lara’s right side stabbed like a shiv.
33. "The trick was to keep the truth hidden, twelve year old Abby Jenkins thought, as she sat listening to the psychologist."
37. The dead girl stood below Gate B4 of New York's Greater Rochester International Airport.
38. Michael could feel the warm blood running down his face.
40. There must be sixty billion dollars on the hoof down there in my living room, and my idiot husband is schmoozing the dollar-ninety-eight seance sister."
41. Something was coming, something not so good - she could feel it, smell it on the furious wind.
42. The Sana Ana winds blew full force this morning – hot and dry, as tree branches slapped against the bedroom window, mercifully waking Irene Carillo from another nightmare..
43. “So…you really don’t know where your underwear might be?”
44. Death turned its sights on me Tuesday morning when dying was the last thing on my mind.
46. The elevator doors opened facing the sign for Children’s Psychiatry and Seth Bellingham froze
48. Lamplight pooled around me, and I felt the eyes of the homeless man move over my body.
49. My first memory of James is what keeps me here, sitting on the floor in the middle of our living room smoothing hair out of a boy’s blood-spattered face.
50. How long does it take an exiled sex goddess to fall to earth?
Okay, first off, bummer to those of you who got culled, but let me tell you that there were only 9 entries that received all three judges' votes. Even when given the choice of the ones who had received only one vote, the judges couldn't agree. A fourth judge was required. Talk about subjective. So, please don't feel badly.
Since it's so obvious readers are attracted to catchy first lines, we're giving anyone who got culled the opportunity to get some feedback from the very talented follower pool at M & M. Here's how to do it. Post your first name (or an alias), give us your original first line, then tell us the premise of the opening scene. We'll see if we can't give you a few good choices.
That said. I decided to post a few "well-know" writer's first lines and let you comment on the ones that work or don't work. You're going to be surprised when I reveal the authors.
1. Max had five minutes.
2. He was never coming back.
3. Sophie Dempsey didn't like Temptation even before the Garveys smashed into her '86 Civic, broke her sister's sunglasses, and confirmed all her worst suspicions about people from small towns who drove beige Cadillacs.
4."It would be easy to kill you while you sleep."
5. No security cameras this time, but he still has to be careful.
6. Making up a boyfriend is nothing new to me.
7. Senator Frederick Wallace of South Carolina rose at dawn from the bed in the lakeside cabin that he had shared with his African-American lover for more than twenty years.
8. she felt his breath.
Let's hear some chatter, folks.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
27 comments:
Oh my gosh, first lines are so important and man, you authors came up with some great ones. Good luck to everyone.
I really like ones that don't just tell me what's happening (even if it's really cool), they leave me with a question about exactly what happened or why something happened. They make me want to read more.
What first lines do you like the best or even what lines confuse you and how would you fix them.
Remember, play nice in the sandbox people, but do come out and play!
I think my favorite is:
Camels.
I mean you have to read on, what is going to happen? Where are they? No what I mean. And I wouldn't fix this one at all.
There were others I liked and I'll have to go over them again to figure out how to fix them. There's one that totally confused me.
I'll be back with that one.
Some great lines. I liked "Camels" too. LOL
I sympathize with the judges. Really. Not an easy task. I like them all!
I have to agree with, Kari. First lines are extremely important to a story. If you can't hook readers with it, they will not turn the page or get to the next scene. It is vital that your first line is great.
My favorites are: 1, 2, 3, 8, 19, 29, 43, 44
Notice, I said favorites...LOL...I don't envy the judges one little bit!
Lynn
Had to delete the last comment for lack of editing!!
Here it is again.
Just a note to the thirty selected first liners to clarify the procedure for sending the last line.
You can start sending them now. Cut off for sending them to liz@lizlipperman.com is tomorrow night, May 7th at 5 PM Central time. Any last line i snot in my mailbox at that time will be automatically eliminated according the original rules of the contest. After the deadline, they will be sent to the new round of judges and posted on Monday, May 10th.
Good luck.
Hey, where's the chatter?
I really liked "Camels" too. You just have to keep reading. What about the camels? Where are they? Loved it.
Some really great lines in there. I wouldn't want to be the judges either.
Tough job. The judges did great on the lines. It's hard to even pick out a favorite.
Thanks for sharing the published lines too. It's fascinating to see the balance. Can't wait to see the how the last line comes through.
Stanalei
I think my 2nd favorite was: Ghosts can be so rude. I don't know how I'd change it. But I just have to keep reading to figure out why they're rude.
#40 I just don't get period. And I have no idea how to make it better. I would stop reading right there. Mostly because I was confused. Not because it was bad or anything.
Oh and I liked "You can't change history with a bulldozer Mr. Maxwell."
That makes me want to know what the heck is he bulldozing and why. And what does it have to do with history.
From this contest I think we've all learned that our perceptions/opinions vary greatly.
For example: Camel. I envision the cigarette, not the animal. Just with that one word sentence I envision an old gumshoe who wished he hadn't quit smoking, but did and now he wished he hadn't. (Because he's had a really bad day).
I lover hearing your favs. And CM, what a different take on the Camels one. Cigarettes was the first thing that popped up in my mind, also - the old controversial Joe Camel. I didn't go as far as you seeing the gumshoe, but I should have. It's a great observation.
What about the rest of you? No takers on the "fix my first line" offer?
What about the published first lines? Any of them jump out at you as not too exciting?
On the lines you posted from famous authors the only ones that jump at me are the short ones. A long convoluted first line looses me.
The shorter the better. I can't wait to see who wrote them though.
Okay, I loved these first lines. This is so much fun. And there was some really great ones.
My favorite was "Camels." But I was thinking animal, not cigarette.
I also loved...
"You can’t rewrite history with a bulldozer, Mr. Maxwell."
The dead girl stood below Gate B4 of New York's Greater Rochester International Airport.
When I was six and she was nine, my cousin Claudia told me to touch the electric fence.
My mother always wanted me to become a beautician, and as I unzipped the body bag of the three-hundred pound corpse, I snapped the lip of my neoprene glove for not heeding her advice.
It started out so innocently -- with a chamois cloth, some silver polish, and a bottle of Brasso.
Sometimes ghosts can be so rude.
The others were good too. I did get confused on the sixty billion dollars on the hoof one. Were there cattle loose in the living room? Or was it a cattle baron down there.
Back in a minute with some suggestions.
The stench of blood can ruin a spring morning. THIS HAS POTENTIAL, BUT COULD USE MORE PUNCH. I I THINK SOME OF THE OTHERS I WOULD’VE CHOSEN FIRST WEREN’T JUST MORE INTRIGUING, BUT THEY HAD BETTER CADENCE. THE WAY THE SENTENCE WAS WORDED HAD A NICE FLOW OFF THE TONGUE.
FOR THIS ONE, WHAT ABOUT… The stench of blood always has a way of ruining a perfect spring morning.
11. Death lurked in the shadows, and I knew it searched for me. GOOD. COULD ALSO SAY...
Death waited in the shadows, and I knew it waited for me.
21. I never thought I would be considered a home wrecker, but it's what I became. GOOD BUT WHAT ABOUT...I never aspired to be a home wrecker, but that's what I came to be.
23, What I wanted would kill me. THIS MIGHT HAVE MORE POWER IF IT WAS GROUNDED TO SOMETHING. SOME CONTRAST OR SETTING. THIS PROBABLY DOESN'T FIT THE STORY BUT IF YOU ADDED SOMETHING LIKE THIS...
What I wanted would kill me, but then I was a dead woman anyway.
33. "The trick was to keep the truth hidden, twelve year old Abby Jenkins thought, as she sat listening to the psychologist." I THINK IF ABBY “STARED” AT THE PSYCHOLOGIST IT WOULD BE MORE POWERFUL.
38. Michael could feel the warm blood running down his face. THIS NEEDS SOMETHING TO CONTRAST WITH. FOR INSTANCE…
Michael could feel the warm blood running down his face as his feet sank into the frigid depths.
44. Death turned its sights on me Tuesday morning when dying was the last thing on my mind. THIS IS GOOD BUT COULD BE BETTER IF YOU ADDED A TIME ON TUESDAY OR SOMETHING TO MAKE IT EVEN MORE TIME CRITICAL, MAKE DEATH SEEM LIKE A LIVE BEING ON THE HUNT. AND EVEN ADD WHAT THE PERSON WAS DOING AT THAT EXACT TIME.
Anita, I agree with all you suggestions except one. Well part I agree, and part I don't. LOL
11. Death lurked in the shadows, and I knew it searched for me.
I like 'lurked' it sounds more sinister than waited. But it also sounds like it's watching, not searching. So the second half I think watched would be better.
Death lurked in the shadows, and I knew it watched me.
My two cents
Good luck to the thirty. Tough job for the judges, but hopefully we'll all learn something.
I think everyone who entered deserves an at a girl or boy for putting the first sentence out for everyone to see.
You all have great imaginations! I love the intake on the smoke/Camels line. Good thinking.
I can't wait to see the next lines. This is really fun!
I think all 30 are better than those of the published authors. Anybody agree with me?
Anita, I love some of your suggestions. I wonder if any of the people will change theirs. Let us know if you do so we can thanks Anita.
Attaboy and attagirl to everyone. Happy, Lindsay?
Chloe and Kimberly - they are fun, aren't they?
Patrick, I laughed when I read your statement. Those are big name authors I've used. I'll reveal them on Saturday.
Truthfully, I've looked at these and don't see how to improve them. The short, punchy ones are my favorites, because I like starting with a punchline. It's like eating dessert first.
As for the famous author lines, the only one I recognize is from--oh, probably shouldn't tell. However, I'd like to read the one that mentions cameras.
Hmm. Pretty sure #3 is one of Jenny Crusie's Temptation books. Thought "Max had five minutes" might be from Roxanne St. Claire's THRILL ME TO DEATH, but I just checked the first line and that's not it!
The only one that made me want to 'really' want to read more was #28.
And I know all newbies are told to have a real punched up first line, I'm rarely compelled by them. Being a fan (of sorts) of Calib Carr and J. Robert Janes, I tend to prefer those long, complicated, paragraph length sentences for openers.
Oh, and I do like #3 of the well-knows.
Patg
Will we get to see the last lines?
Post a Comment