Please welcome guest blogger Cleo Coyle. Cleo and I are actually swapping posts today. While she’s here, I’m over at her usual Friday spot at www.MysteryLoversKitchen.com. So after you’ve met Cleo, come on over to the kitchen for a visit. ~ Liz
First a big thank you to Liz Lipperman and the lovely ladies of Mysteries and Margaritas for inviting me to be their guest. Today I’d like to tell you about the moment I decided to become a genre writer. Yes, I can trace it back to the exact nanosecond. It happened during my senior year of college, going on twenty years now yet still shatteringly clear.
One of my professors, an award-winning poet, was teaching a course on writing magazine features. The lanky, bearded instructor stood there, in front of the silent class, slowly shaking his head. Sad. So sad…
What? Did someone die? As far as he was concerned, the answer was yes. You see, a female friend of his had landed a book contract at a “big New York publishing house.” The New York Times noticed this woman’s novel, giving it a few column inches in the back of their Book Review. Unfortunately, the review was negative and dismissive.
What the professor said next would affirm my professional decisions for years to come: “Just a few column inches,” he said, “and her career is over.”
Excuse me?
I grew up in a small town outside of Pittsburgh, PA. My mother was a telephone order clerk with a beautician’s license; my father was a steel worker. I’d never met anyone who made his or her living writing fiction. The mere idea seemed as likely for me as picnicking on Pluto. Yet even I knew that my professor’s opinion on his friend’s career was completely full of crap.
If you want to write me off as some backward bumpkin, think again. After graduating from Carnegie Mellon University, I went to work for The New York Times as a cub reporter. I then went on to work for several major publishing companies where I created and oversaw book programs attached to major media properties. Yes, I studied poetry and literary fiction in college and even won a minor poetry award, but I did not find my bliss in the hushed halls of academia or the quiet confines of small presses. Why?
I love popular culture, that’s why. And I love story: lively, passionate, plot-driven story; tales with arcs and acts and cliffhangers; daring misdirection; larger-than-life characters; treachery, hilarity, and tear-welling drama. As far as my legacy as a writer, I would rather have the average man (or woman) on the street remember my character’s name (e.g., Scrooge, Scarlett, Tarzan, Miss Marple) than my own.
Some argue that genre is confining. I disagree. So does P.D. James, who described the story structure of mystery as freeing to her as an author, allowing her to explore any number of themes, characters, and settings. Blending two or more genres provides the author an even larger palette to create unique and beautiful tales (Charlaine Harris). And I firmly believe that growing as a writer is a stronger possibility if we’re practicing for an audience, just as all creative artists practice: dancers, actors, playwrights, musicians…
Yes, I know Emily Dickinson spent her life isolated and unpublished, but we’re in a new world now. Would Emily have posted her verse on Facebook? Would she have tweeted? Would she have lurked around blogs and left wise and quirky little comments? She sought publication in her lifetime, didn’t she? She sought an audience.
I wish I could speak to that professor now, ask him to stand back, way back, far enough to get some real-world perspective. Some of the most beloved and widely recited poetry today isn’t found in the New Yorker. It’s in our iPods.
And, speaking of lyricists, I watched an interesting YouTube video the other day. Click the link to see to see Pearl Jam, one of the most influential musical groups of the 1990s, talking about their writing process: http://www.youtube.com/user/pearljamofficial?blend=1&ob=4
I found their short, little film to be full of inspiring truths of the writing life, whether one is writing lyrics, composing music, or creating fictional worlds for tens of thousands of readers.
So that’s my story; and I hope, on days when you’re feeling dismissed or dejected, you’ll think of that sad, so sad shake of a professor’s head and know that your career need not end because of a few column inches in a book review broadsheet.
You are a writer whose work goes straight to the heart of a readership excited to see what you’ll come up with next. You’re writing for bright, literate people who are truly grateful for your storytelling abilities. Don’t stop writing. Your audience is not the critics. It’s the readers. Don’t let them down.
Your turn: What genres do you write in and why do you love them? Or if you’re a reader, what draws you to your favorite genre or authors? Or answer me this: Do review quotes matter to you?
-----------------------
Cleo Coyle is the pseudonym a multipublished author and New York Times bestselling media tie-in writer. She is currently writing two mystery series for Penguin in collaboration with her husband: The Haunted Bookshop Mysteries and The Coffeehouse Mysteries. On What Grounds, the first book in her Coffeehouse series, was not reviewed by Publishers Weekly, Library Journal, or Kirkus. The title is now in its 15th printing. By book #7, those publications finally took notice, giving Espresso Shot favorable reviews, including a starred review from Library Journal. (Cleo’s advice: Go forth and write, fellow authors, regardless of reviews.)

Today Cleo is also sharing an instant giveaway. Her new release in August, Roast Mortem, is the 9th book in her Coffeehouse Mystery series. The murder mystery revolves around a heroic group of New York firefighters, not unlike these actual members of the FDNY…
In celebration of Roast Mortem’s theme, Cleo is giving away a copy of The California Firehouse Cookbook today. To win the book, simply leave a comment or question. Cleo will randomly select the winner here and post it at her website www.CoffeehouseMystery.com tonight at 11 PM (Eastern Time).
48 comments:
what a great post Cleo!
I am writing a MG series called The Samantha Granger Experiment and book one Fused comes out November 1st 2010.
I am also writing a cozy mystery series for Berkley called The Fortune Teller Mystery Series and book one Tea Leaves to Die For comes out September 1st 2011.
I admit I'm terrified of what my first review will say, but now you make it seem less scary. That the readers are the people who matter and maybe my career won't be over if I get a bad review.
Thanks for putting it all in perspective :-)
I'm off to check out your books...they sound fabulous!
Cleo, just popped in to say I loved the Pearl Jam video. It is all about the words.
Thanks for joining us today. Gotta hop over to your blog now.
Cleo, thanks for the introduction to a new website. Took a quick tour, but I will be back...
I am too old to write, barely can spell (truth is, i can't spell without spellchecker, and I always forget to capitalize I).
But I read and buy books, doesn't that help the rest of you??
Reply to -
@Kari - I'm very glad to know my post helped put some perspective on reviews. This is one of many reasons that I love readers who enjoy genres - mystery, romance, fantasy, SF. They go to the bookstore with open minds, actively looking for new author in the genres they know and love. In most cases, reviews just don't factor in. Other things matter, it seems to me - storyline, freshness, voice, themes. All in all, a pretty fantastic tribe to gather around your storytelling fire!
I'm looking forward to both of your series, too - especially the Fortune Teller Mysteries. My husband has been a tarot reader for most of his life. He learned it from his grandmother. So I'm really jazzed about your theme! Thanks for the great comment.
~Cleo
Coffeehouse Mystery.com
Cleo Coyle on Twitter
Replies to -
@Liz - thanks again, Liz, for inviting me to join you and the M&M crew today. This is such a great blog. Great posts and interviews (I'm a follower, of course!)
@Dave - Aren't these ladies amazingly talented? This is a wonderful blog to discover. I'm glad you dropped in for a virtual margarita! Good luck on winning the cookbook, too. It benefits a 9/11 charity. So it's win-win for everyone.
~ Cleo
Coffeehouse Mystery.com
Cleo Coyle on Twitter
I just discovered your coffee house series and now I am finding you all over the Net. I joined your mailing list yesterday. Now I am looking forward to delving into your backlist.
Welcome to the M&M's Cleo. I loved the post. But then I forgot it all when I saw the Firemen, gotta love those guys. Mmm...
Just kidding. Thank you as Kari said, for putting everything into perspective.
Cleo,
Thanks for a fun and informative post. I think most college professors, bearded or not, are good at shaking their head. At least to their children-know this from experience.
I write romantic suspense with a touch, or more depending of the story, of military, Army, in the story. It's fun, interesting and presents unique challenges intergrating the Army into the story.
As far as reviews go, I've had my fair share-good so far. The reviews force me to write at or above that level so I won't let my reader down, which none of us want to do.
I don't think I've ever NOT read a book because of bad reviews. The reviewer doesn't know me or my mind. I tend to read authors who amuse and entertain, not what some reviewer says about the story.
Least we forget, a review is one person's opinion, at that particular time in the whole space-time continuum thingie.
Reviews-good, bad or indifferent shouldn't effect the way we write.
Don't know about the rest out there but-I live to write and write to live.
Terrific post! I'm going to check out your books -- and I hope I win one today!
JoAnne Ross posted a fun video about bad reviews.
I'm resurrecting a cross genre book -- a paranormal with romance, suspense and humor.
Cleo, first, I'd like to say how much the women in my family love your books. I'm sure the men would, too, if we could get them to read. :-) Your post makes perfect sense. I've never purchased books or selected movies based on the reviews of critics. I like to form my own opinion. I think most people are like that.
As an unpubbed writer of light contemporary romance, I can only hope when I am published, I'll adopt the same healthy attitude toward reviews.
I am an avid reader (I usually finish a "normal" book in about 2 days)- and have always loved mysteries. As the busy mom of 6 kids this is my escape - my me time. It is also what I do while I'm waiting at all of the music lessons, sports practices, dr/dentist/ortho appointments. (Love when a book fits in my purse) I am always looking for a new series to read - and I enjoy characters that are "real" and getting to know them over several books. Since it is an escape for me I generally like the series of mysteries that are "lighter" reads (and recipes are always fun) and not the dark and gorey ones. I always refer to them as "mind candy"
And no I don't care about reviews - I wouldn't even know where to look for the reviews - I love to browse the library and bookstores to find what catches my eye or use the recommendations of friends or fun blogs like this and "mystery lovers kitchen" And once I find an author I like - they become like a friend and I want to read all of thier books.
Hi, Cleo
I just want to say that first of all, I absolutely love your books (especially the Haunted Bookshop series) and I can't wait for the next one to come out!
In the past, I did all kinds of creative writing for class like poetry, short stories, prose and my teachers loved them. Sadly, I stopped writing because I did not have time.
Now, I am a fourth year in college hoping to publish my own story some day! I have to say that the mystery genre is my absolute favorite. There are so many ways to be creative with it! I currently only write fanfiction since my writing has become rusty from lack of practice.In the fanfiction community, I write a lot of humor and romance. I enjoy writing humor because I hope that it makes someone laugh and forget the bad day that they just had at work. I hope that writing these fanfiction as practice will help bring my writing up to par so that I can write for a larger audience in the future.
Cleo, imagine me standing up and cheering right now. Great post, and right on!!
I love mysteries and I'm not all that picky on what type of mystery as long as I can appreciate the protag in some way and it's well written. Reviews as a rule mean very little to me.I bought the book Jitterbug Perfume years ago because it was panned everywhere and I loved it. I still keep a copy at home.
I like both fantasy and have gotten very interested in mysteries lately -- funny being in Sisters in Crime I hear about great authors!
I am a library director and being a member has helped my collection development greatly!
Lynn
Great post! I love your coffeehouse mysteries. I never pay attention to reviews. I write and work in a bookstore and it's the book that sells me, not a review. It might have something to do with being stubborn and independent and hate being told who and what to like. I make up my own mind. I also have won and lost a lot of writing contests. I always get the judges that hate or love what I write. I can only imagine the reviews that will come when I'm published. :)
I write romantic thrillers set in Alaska about ordinary people in extraordinary situations.
I'm going to go and check out the YouTube video now! Thanks again for the post.
Your professor said that because he was inside the academic culture, which disdains mainstream publishing, methinks. I was married to a professor whom the university found inordinately embarrassing because he published in science fiction and fantasy. He did over 200 books. It was a big problem for them.
My dad only pubbed academia but was a closet Madd magazine reader
I'm a reviewer for a national magazine that carries many book reviews. Some books have been awful, and some wonderful, but I try to find something redemptive or worthwhile in most books. Sometimes it isn't easy. I don't think a ho-hum review is likely to sink a career; I often wonder who buys the books that seem like they were edited in a basement during a tornado. There's something for everyone.
What a great perspective on genre writing, Cleo! Another thing that I think genre books do is hook reluctant readers. Right now, books have *so* much competition in the entertainment arena.
An iffy review isn't going to stop most readers from reading a book they're interested in.
Inspiring post, Cleo! Wow, 15 printings--cool beans! (had to try to squeeze in the coffee reference)
Cleo - that was one wonderful post! Thanks for giving us so much to think about.
Literary works--and prizes--have their place, but I'd much rather be a modern-day Charles Dickens and hold readers captive through popular fiction.
And in answer to your question, I write romance on the sweeter side, which I love because there's nothing more satisfying to me than to see two people overcome obstacles--internal or external--to arrive at their happy ending.
Barbara
www.barbarawhitedaille.com
Cleo:
I'm a big fan of your coffeehouse mysteries, recipes and blog. As someone who is writing a kid's fantasy for fun (I'm going to try to get it published, but I know it's a long shot) I found this blog post particularly helpful. Often I get stuck, or blocked when I'm writing, worried about what a reviewer might think of the story. Thanks for putting it in perspective. I am curious, however, what happened to the author your professor spoke about?
On a completely unrelated note, I'm glad you are looking into the Cops & Doughnuts Shop and Cops Coffee!
And, I’m looking forward to checking out the Casserole Lovers Series in 2011 :)
Thank you to everyone for these wonderful comments! Coming back soon to give more specific replies.
Wow, Cleo, these ladies are a hoot!
Your books sound like fun and I love fun.
I read just about anything but I write paranormal, women's fiction, and romantic suspense. I've been a story teller for as long as I can remember, so wen I retired from teaching I decided to write stories to share. Characters bug me until I write about them.
Lately I've fallen in love with several mystery writers.
Replies to --
@Anonymous - Thank you – that’s very nice of you and I truly appreciate it. :) I can only hope my books entertain. My website carries a lot of bonus features and posts for my readers. I hope you'll have fun with those, too: Coffeehouse Mystery.com
@Mary - Oh, yes! Those FDNY firefighters do tend to be a distraction for the opposite sex -- and (believe me) I make good use of that idea in Roast Mortem, lol!
@Lindsay - Beautifully put - "I live to write and write to live." I was so pleased to see your comment. I really enjoyed your interview on this site the other day (Everyone - check out the interview with Lindsay Downs. It was posted June 9, via Cassie's Corner on this blog!) And I'm looking forward to reading you. Also, LOL on the shaking of the professorial head. Sounds like you lived with it a helluva lot longer than I did! :)
~ Cleo
Cleo,
Reading me is hard because the ink tends to run. But, reading my books is fun and enjoyable.
Replies to...
@Edie - That video is priceless! Thank you for sharing. :) Also - your book sounds like it's right on the mark for today's mass market. I remember when "paranormal" was a tiny, weird "woo-woo" niche. Clearly, those days are over!
@June - To the women in your family, I convey my heartfelt thanks. To the men, my recipe for Cuppa Joe Mocha Drops: Click here to get my recipe in PDF, lol! :) Thank you for the nice comment, and I do hope you'll keep this post in mind when your own book hits print!
Crazy Momma - I really appreciate your candid thoughts about what's important to you as a reader; why you read; how you select books. "...once I find an author I like - they become like a friend and I want to read all of their books." Nicely put and I think any author would be downright thrilled to hear a reader say that about his or her work.
~ Cleo
(more replies to come...)
Lindsay - Oh, snap! Teacher boy, ain't you gonna let me get away with no street talk here?! Well, shoot!:)
~Cleo
Queens, NYC
Longtime Home to Hip-Hop
Cleo,
FYI-I speak two languages. English and bad English so you can street talk me all you want and I probably won't have a clue if you're saying nice things to me or not.
Just checked out the recipe for the cookies in the comment above. Forget it-to complicated.
I can barely boil water.
Replies to...
@Peas and carrots - Thank you kindly. The Haunted Bookshop is very close to my heart and I'm glad to know that you are enjoying the series. Funny that you mentioned fan fiction. Just the other day, I was saying to my husband (and collaborator) that anyone wanting to embark on storytelling as a career, really should be able to take a beloved universe and spin new tales out of established characters and settings. Fan fiction is a great starting point to begin playing the scales on your instrument (so to speak). The next step, of course, is finding your own song. I hope you do -- and enjoy the journey of finding it. That's key.
@Shel - Bless your genre-lovin' heart, girl! Thanks. :)
@Mare F. - I'm with you. I have GOT to read a book with the title Jitterbug Perfume! Thank you for that great comment.
~ Cleo
(more replies to come...)
Cleo, thanks for the cookie recipe! I'm trying it this weekend. Wish I could cook them up tonight. Thanks again.
Tiffinie,
Can I have some cookies also. I promise to be a good boy but won't eat my veggies.
Please. Please. Please.
Replies to...
@Lynn - Sisters in Crime is a fantastic group and I'm glad to hear that you're finding new favorites there -- especially given that you're a library director! (IMHO, librarians are among the coolest people on the planet. :)
@Tiffinie - I'm writing this at about 1 AM New York time, so I know who won today's random drawing, and it was you! Congratualations! And (BTW) a thriller set in Alaska sounds pretty terrific to me. Thank you for your kind words about my coffeehouse mysteries and good luck to you on the (often bumpy but ultimately fulfilling) road to publication!
~ Cleo
Lindsay, you do the dishes and you can have some. I don't care if you eat your veggies or not. I don't plan to. :)
YES!!!!! This is so great! I never win at anything like this. And I badly wanted this book. I'm headed to Alaska to commerical fish this summer and this book will come in handy feeding us fisherman. Thank you so much! Woo-hoo!
Tiffinie - You are most welcome. And your plan to use it to feed you and your fellow commercial fishermen sounds just about perfect. May you cook and eat with joy!
Carol-Lynn - your husband wrote over 200 SF books? (His name wasn't Isaac Asimov, was it?!) And you're darn right academia disdains mainstream publishing. You'd get less grief putting a crucifix in front of a vampire than a genre novel in front of an MFA professor. Good thing my audience is the reading public. :)
Replies to...
@Cheapsunglasses - thank you for that. It's good to know! And I think most genre reviewers are earnest fans of the genres that they review and as kind as you in their approach.
I want you to know that I'm not at all ranting about reviews being bad or negative. My concern for fellow authors is that they know that continuing to write is what matters. Only if we keep working at it can we get better. And in this endeavor, "getting better" lasts a lifetime.
~Cleo
Replies to
@Elizabeth - Thank you for dropping in, E! Counting the days for the release of your own baby - Delicious and Suspicious. :)
@Alan - LOL. Enjoyed your "perky" pun. (Sorry, couldn't resist!)
@Barbara - Couldn't put it any better! Lifting up readers is an amazing occupation. And their kind appreciation makes what we do more than worth it.
~ Cleo
NiGeLa - Thank you for all the wonderful points of your comment! I'm so glad that you are liking my books and blogging. And I'm tickled that you already noticed the Cops Coffee! Isn't that hilarious? I can't wait to taste it. They tell me they'll be selling it online in a few weeks. Finally, I'm very happy to know that my post today helped give you some perspective. One of the key moments in an author's growth is his or her ability to shut out what others will think. Reach down deep and come up again with what is true -- and truly your voice -- and you'll be okay as a writer. I could quote any number of impressive sources to get my meaning across, but (frankly) the little fish in Finding Nemo said it the most succinctly: "just keep swimming..." :)
Mary - I love how you put it: "Characters bug me until I write about them." That's exactly how I feel, especially about my character Jack Shepard, the dead private investigator who haunts a Rhode Island book store (in my Haunted Bookshop mysteries). When characters haunt a writer, that's a *very* good thing.
Cheers and thanks again to Liz and the ladies of Mysteries and Margaritas for inviting me to guest post today.
Good night, everyone!
~ Cleo
P.S. Lindsay: I can just picture your professor dad, laughing in his easy chair with a stack of Mad Magazines on his lap. I have a couple of film suggestions for you (if you have not seen them yet): THE SQUID AND THE WHALE and MUSIC AND LYRICS, preferably screened back-to-back! :)
Great post. To answer your questions, I write romantic suspense--love a guaranteed happy ending. AND I pay attention to major reviews...normally believing the opposite. LOL So no, reviews mean absolutely nothing to me as a reader.
Angi - "...normally believing the opposite." Ha! Thank you for your great comment. (I think, at one time or another, we all feel as though we've fallen down the rabbit hole!)
~ Cleo
Coffeehouse Mystery.com
Cleo Coyle on Twitter
NiGeLa - Thanks for the comment about buying the Casserole Series in 2011. Woo Hoo! My first sale!!
Thanks, Cleo for this great blog.
Liz,
Guess that makes me your second sale but the first signed.
Post a Comment